January 2009
Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun
« Dec   Feb »
 1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031  

Day January 31, 2009

The Better Angels of Our Nature

A friend asked me about a theme that seems to run through my blogs–emotion.  She asked why I seem so intent on not allowing my emotions to have bearing on my reactions.  As a professional counselor, she has a different perspective on emotion than most others do. I started working on this yesterday, and I’d like to finish and post it now because God knows I won’t be available during the Super Bowl.  (The Steelers are damn good, but Arizona is my second home, so I have to root for the Cardinals!)

Emotion is a thing that humans truly corner the market on.  We’re the only creatures on this planet that experience it so intensely.  We’re the only beings on Earth who are so driven by it that we often become a boon to ourselves.  That’s not to say that emotion is necessarily a bad thing; I’m not saying that all emotion is harmful.  But it holds a power over each and every one of us that we’ve become programmed to accept subconsciously.  It’s as if we’re taught from a young age now to simply obey whatever we feel.  Whereas it used to be more common to discourage acting on impulse, we can see from the YouTube generation that impulse is almost all we recognize anymore.  Our impulse is driven by our emotions.

It’s natural for teenagers to be impulsive.  You teach a child to do what’s right; sometimes you catch them with their hand in the cookie jar, and you may spank them, but eventually they learn.  Once they become teenagers, their bodies start changing, their chemicals and hormones start reacting differently, and they start facing the prospect of going out on their own.  They have to learn lessons that will carry them through life.  When I was in junior high school in Houston, a program was developed that taught kids that “if it comes from inside you, then it’s good and you should trust it.”  When kids would beat me up–I still remember this–there would always be one teacher who wanted to tan their hides, yet the principal would want to sit us down, have a talk, and ask the kid who had pummeled me why they felt the need to do it.  It would go something like this: “Eugene, why did you pin Mel down and punch her?”  “Because I don’t like her!”  “Well, why don’t you like her?”  “She’s an idiot!”  “Eugene, we don’t call people names.  Why don’t you like her?”  “Because…she’s annoying!  I just don’t like her!  Everyone hates her!”

That conversation actually took place, and it goes on still today.  When I was much younger, you were paddled for the slightest infraction.  As I got older things changed and I barely noticed it until I had to look back at it and realized the stark differences.  Somewhere along the way, society started deliberately putting more emphasis on emotions, on feelings, as a means by which to gauge how we should behave.  It has resulted in the vast majority of people, whether they realize they’re doing it or not, reacting based entirely on what they feel rather than what they think.  “How do you feel about that” has become the question of the century.  We practically define ourselves by it now.

It has been reflected most of all in our political leanings.  “WAR IS NEVER THE ANSWER!”  Alright…why?  What made you come to this conclusion?  “THE DEATH PENALTY IS WRONG!”  Why?  On what is that statement based?  “YOU’RE SO INTOLERANT!”  What makes me intolerant?  “YOU CAN’T IMPOSE YOUR MORALITY ON ME!  MORALITY IS RELATIVE!”  Okay–then I’m your fault.  “WE NEED CHANGE!!!”  From what?  Exactly what needs to be changed, and how do you propose it be changed?  Are you willing to go for whatever change is offered for the sake of change, or have you actually given thought to the fact that things could, in fact, get much worse?

One of the hardest lessons I’ve learned in this life is that you cannot trust your emotions completely.  I have watched myself tear good friendships apart because I spent more time reacting emotionally rather than rationally.  I’ve made a lot of poor decisions in my past because I was more interested in feeding an emotional need instead of taking the time to question myself.  Ironically, it was the epiphany that I might be gay that first taught me to question how I feel.  Since then, I’ve had many experiences that have tested my faith in myself.  I’ve learned to think carefully before I react, even though I don’t always succeed in being logical first.  I’m human; human beings are the most thick-skulled, self-absorbed, stubborn creatures on the planet, and I’m no exception to the rule.

My friend, the counselor, thinks I’m just going through a period of far-opposite reactions to past experiences and that I’ll learn to embrace my emotional responses again someday.  Maybe.  For now, I just wish more people would stop feeling and start thinking.  Emotion can be an amazing thing when you’ve found the love of your life and they reciprocate your feelings.  But when deciding the fate of the free world, emotion now stands to do more damage than any of us realizes.  I believe with all my heart that was what Abraham Lincoln spoke of when he addressed the rumors of civil war after becoming the President:

“I am loath to close. We are not enemies, but friends. We must not be enemies. Though passion may have strained it must not break our bonds of affection. The mystic chords of memory, stretching from every battlefield and patriot grave to every living heart and hearthstone all over this broad land, will yet swell the chorus of the Union, when again touched, as surely they will be, by the better angels of our nature.”  –Abraham Lincoln in his first inaugural address

Open Letter to the Gay Community

To all of my GLBT counterparts in America:

I’m reading a lot of things today that are turning my stomach.  I’m ashamed of the things I’m hearing and seeing.  Despite repeated calls from all of us for more tolerance of our different way of living and loving, we are showing hatred and intolerance like never before.  In light of the passage of Proposition 8, I can understand that many of us are upset.  However, it saddens me to see us reacting in such a way.

Conservative or liberal, we all have the same thing in common: we’re all gay.  Being politically conservative doesn’t make myself, Philip or Steve any less same-sex attracted as you.  It doesn’t make us any less human.  It doesn’t mean we don’t want to reach the same goals as you do as far as our rights go.  We are all connected through that.  However, we are being called on to answer to the actions that we do not approve of because of that connection, things that are completely counter-productive to reaching our goals. 

With the court’s decision not to keep private the names of those who donated money to the Yes On 8 campaign, people from our community have begun harassing and at times openly threatening those whose names are on the list of donors.  Here are some examples:

“Did you know you work for a judgmental bigot? I know I could not work for someone who encourages bigotry and hate.”

“What goes around comes around, and now you’re going to experience the comes around part. Have fun.”

The first quote was in an email to the employees of a real estate agent in California.  The second was in a voice mail to the same person.  Several business owners have reported repeated threatening voice mails, emails and visits from people angry about the passage of Proposition 8.  Several high-level managers of various businesses have been forced to resign in the wake of such harassment in order to protect the businesses they worked for and the other employees that were being negatively affected. 

You’re calling them hatemongers.  You’re calling them intolerant.  You’re calling them bigots.  And you are doing the very thing you are accusing them of–hating people you disagree with and doing everything you can to upend their lives.  Like the religious leaders who persecuted other denominations during the flegling years of America’s independence, you are becoming the very thing you say you’re trying to stop.  You are not the only ones who will be affected by this sort of behavior; all of us will pay for it in the end. 

I implore all of you to think before you speak and act.  Ask yourself how being so emotional might impact those around you.  Question your judgement before you call or email somebody–will this have a positive impact on our common cause, or will it only serve to strengthen the resolve of those who disagree with us?  Like it or not, there will always be more straight people in this world than there are GLBT folks.  If we want to have equal footing, we need to prove that we’re worth it.

From now on, I will be in partnership with those targeted by your hatred.  I may disagree with some of their beliefs, but I also believe in their right to disagree and I’d rather work with them than against them.  Any phone numbers, email addresses, ISP’s and names I can collect that are linked to Prop 8 rage, I will publish it here to expose you.  I will not tolerate the open hypocrisy perpetrated by my own community.  I don’t like being called a traitor, but hopefully, in time, you’ll understand.  I’d rather do what’s best for us than continue to allow us to be our own worst enemies.

Sincerely,

Mel Maguire

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 347 other followers